THE AUSTRALIAN STORY
Lord Beauchamp's Report from Committee inquiring into the Transportation Act of 1784.
Your Committee begs to inform the House, That, in further Execution of their Orders, they directed their Chairman to apply to Lord Sydney, his Majesty's Secretary of State for the Home Department, for copies of all Plans which have been submitted to Government for the transportation of Criminals . . . That his Lordship, in Answer, informed the Committee, that different Ideas had been suggested on the Subject, but that such Suggestions were either made in Conversation, or appeared, from the Nature of them, unworthy of the Attention of the Committee, and that no such Plan as was required existed in his Office. . . .
That the Committee are far from arraigning the late Increase in the Number of public Executions, though they lament them the more, because these Sacrifices to Public Justice have produced no other Effect than the Removal of the Offenders in Question; and that Crimes still multiply, in Defiance of the severest Exertions of Justice.
The Committee further observe, That these Mischiefs are in great Measure to be attributed to the Want of a proper Place for the Transportation of Criminals - That the old system of Transporting to America, answered every good Purpose which could be expected from it - That it tended directly to reclaim the Objects on which it was inflicted, and to render them good Citizens . . . That it tended to break down, in their Infancy, those Gangs and Combinations which have since proved so injurious to the Community . . . That the Colonies seem to have been sensible of the beneficial Consequences of this Practice - That the Convicts whose Labour was so purchased were usually removed into the Back Country, and finding none of the Temptations, in that new State of Things, which occasioned their Offences at Home, it does not appear that the Police or Peace of the Colonies suffered in any considerable Degree by them.
The Committee further observe, on the Nature of Transportation, that though the next Punishment, in Point of Severity, to a Capital Sentence, it answers very imperfectly the Purpose of Example - That though a transported Convict may suffer under his Sentence, his Sufferings are unseen; That his Chasm is soon filled up, and, being as soon forgotten, it strikes no Terror into the Minds of those for whose Correction it was intended to operate, though the Public may gain very importantly by his Removal. . . .
The Committee observe . . . That, therefore, their Enquiry will be confined to such Portions of the Continent as are comprehended in the limits of no European State - That it appears to this Committee, that a vast Tract of Country, answering this Description, lies on the West Coast of Africa, between Twenty and Thirty Degrees of South Latitude . . . That this Coast has been seldom visited by any Europeans, and that it does not appear that any Settlers whatever are to be found on any Part of it, tho' the Soil is fertile, productive of the best Herbage, and abounds with great Herds of wild Cattle, as Sheep, Horses, and Cows, and also all the Animals and Birds peculiar to the Tropical Climates . . . That in the more Mountainous Parts, particularly near the great River Das Voltas, there is a Vein of Copper Ore which contains One Third of pure Metal . . . That the Bay and River of Das Voltas would be an excellent Place for the Homeward-bound Indiamen . . . That it might also promote the Purposes of future Commerce or of future Hostility in the South Seas. . . .
Recommendations for the Disposal of Convicts, 1785 .
The Committee also observe, That if the Convicts are landed before the Month of November . . . they will have the whole Summer to raise Habitations, and make other Preparations for their future Subsistence and Security - That among the Convicts now sentenced specifically to Africa, or whose Place of Transportation depends on His Majesty, it will be proper to select for this service Artificers, Mechanics, and Husbandmen, though, if the latter should be wanting, it will not be material, as in such Climates as are usually found between 20 and 30 degrees of South Latitude, the Cultivation of Land requires very little Skill or Labour.
The Committee further observe . . . That many American Families are desirous of settling in any healthy Part of the Globe where they can rely on the Protection of the British Government; and that they will readily resort to the Coast in Question, under proper Encouragement to do so - That Settlers of this Description will be very Instrumental in keeping the Convicts in due Subordination; and that their Labour may be assigned to them, under proper Restrictions - That if the Colony should flourish and become numerous, it may prove the Means of Annually relieving the Gaols of the Kingdom; and that it is desirable to divert the Spirit of Emigration, which leads so many British Subjects Annually to the United States, to Countries which are still subject to the Crown of Great Britain - That all Discoveries as well as great Commercial Establishments now existing in distant Parts of the Globe . . . have opened the Way to the greatest National Advantages. . . .
On considering the Whole of the Subject, the Committee are of Opinion, That if the Legislature persists in the System of Transporting Criminals to Africa, the scheme now suggested is the only One which appears to them of a practicable Nature; yet, as it will not answer the Purpose of annual Transportation, unless it becomes a numerous and flourishing Colony, which will require for many Years the foster Hand of the Mother Country, the Committee recommend the Adoption of it, so far only as the Commercial and Political Benefits of a Settlement on the South West Coast of Africa may be deemed of sufficient Consequence to warrant the Expence inseparable from such an Undertaking, at the same Time that it restores Energy to the Execution of the Law, and contributes to the interior Police of this Kingdom.
Thomas Butterworth Bailey, Esquire, an acting Magistrate for the County of Lancashire, being examined, acquainted the Committee, That the Magistrates at Quarter Sessions have experienced great Difficulties in inflicting the Punishment of Transportation for Seven Years, the Sentence being for Transportation generally, to some Parts beyond the Seas, as the Magnitude of the Punishment is rendered very uncertain, from the Difference of the Climate and Country to which they may be sent, and from the Uncertainty of the Offenders being able to return after the Expiration of the Term.
- That under this Embarrassment they have sentenced Persons to Imprisonment in England for different Terms, whom otherwise they would have sentenced to Transportation. - That in consequence of this a very great Accumulation of Prisoners has taken place in the County Gaol, and other Prisons, where there is not Accommodation for them. . . . That some of them have been confined Three Years, or Three Years and a Half, since they were sentenced to Transportation -That there is no stated County Allowance - That they are maintained under discretionary Orders from the Magistrates when they visit the Prisons - And that, if the Law remains as it is, the Evil will be greatly increased. . . .
Overcrowded Gaols, 1785.
Richard Akeman, Esquire . . . acquainted the Committee, That in a few Days the Number of Prisoners in his Custody [i.e. at Newgate] will amount to 600, owing to the Influx from other Goals, for the Purpose of Trial at the ensuing Sessions - That the present Number is double of what it was usually was Five or Six Years ago - and that that, from the full State of Goal, it has happened that Convicts under Sentence of Death could not be kept in separate Cells as was usually the Practice.
An Act for effectual Transportation of Felons and other Offenders; and to authorise the Removal of Prisoners in certain Cases; and for other Purposes therein mentioned. 24 Geo. III c. 56 (1784)
Whereas it is expedient to impower his Majesty, with the Advice of his Privy Council, to appoint certain Places, as well out of his Majesty's Dominions as within the same, to which Felons and other Offenders may be transported, and to make other Regulations for the more effectual Transportation of such Offenders; may it therefore please your Majesty that it may be enacted; and be it enacted by the King's most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and Consent of the Lords Spiritual and Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the Authority of the same, That from and after the passing of this Act, when any Person, or Persons, at any Session of Oyer and Terminer, or Gaol Delivery, or at any other Quarter or General Session of the Peace, to be holden for any County, Riding, Division, City, Town, Borough, Liberty or Place, within that Part of Great Britain called England, or at any Great Session to be holden for the County Palatine of Chester, or within the Principality of Wales, shall be lawfully convicted of Grand or Petit Larceny, or any other Offence for which such Person or Persons shall be liable by the Laws of this Realm to be transported, it shall and may be lawful for the Court before which any such Person or Persons shall be so convicted as aforesaid, or any subsequent Court holden at any Place for the same County, Riding, Division, City, Town, Borough, Liberty or Place respectively, with like Authority, to order and adjudge that that such Person or Persons so convicted as aforesaid shall be transported beyond the Seas, for any Term of Years, not exceeding the Number of Years or Term for which such Person or Persons is or are, or shall be liable by any Law to be transported; and, in every such Case, it shall and may be lawful for his Majesty, by and with the Advice of his Privy Council, to declare and appoint to what Place or Places, Part or Parts beyond the Seas, either within his Majesty's Dominions, or elsewhere out of his Majesty's Dominions, such Felons or other Offenders shall be conveyed or transported; and such Court as aforesaid is hereby authorised and impowered to order such Offenders to be transferred to the Use of any Person or Persons, and his or their Assigns, who shall contract for the due Performance of such Transportation: And when his Majesty, his Heirs and Successors, shall be pleased to extend Mercy to any Offender or Offenders who hath or have been, or shall be convicted of any Crime or Crimes for which he, she, or they, is, are, or shall be by Law excluded from the Benefit of Clergy, upon Condition of Transportation to any Place or Places, Part or Parts beyond the Seas, either for Term of Life, or any Number of Years, and such Intention of Mercy shall be signified by one of his Majesty's Principal Secretaries of State, it shall be lawful for any Court having proper Authority,
Decision to Renew Transportation. 1784.
to allow such Offender or Offenders the benefit of a conditional Pardon, and (except in Cases where such Offender or Offenders shall be authorised by his Majesty to transport himself, herself or themselves) to order the Transfer of such Offender or Offenders to any Person or Persons who shall contract for the due Performance of such Transportation, and his or their Assigns, for such and the same Term of Years for which any such Offender or Offenders shall have been ordered to be transported, or for such Term of Life or Years for which any such Offender or Offenders shall have been ordered to be transported, or for such Term of Life or Years as shall be specified in such Condition of Transportation as aforesaid; and such Person or Persons so contracting as aforesaid, his or their Assigns, by virtue of such Order of Transfer as aforesaid, shall have a Property in the Service of such Offender or Offenders for such Terms respectively; and when any Offender or Offenders hath or have been, or shall be convicted of any Crime or Crimes for which he, she, or they is or are by Law excluded from Benefit of Clergy, the Judge, before whom such Offender or Offenders shall be convicted, or any Justice of the King's Bench, Common Pleas, or Baron of the Exchequer of the Degree of the Coif, in case the said Offender or Offenders shall have been tried at any Court of Oyer and Terminer, or Gaol Delivery, in England, or any Justice of Chester or Wales, in case the said Offender or Offenders shall be tried and convicted within any of their respective Jurisdictions, may, on such Intention of Mercy as aforesaid being signified to him by one of the said Principal Secretaries of State, make an order for the immediate Transportation of such Offender or Offenders, in the same Manner as if such Intention of Mercy had been signified by one of the said Principal Secretaries of State during the Continuance of the Assizes or Sessions at which such Offender or Offenders was or were condemned; and such Order shall be considered as an Order made at such Assizes or Sessions as aforesaid, and shall be as effectual, and have all the same Consequences as any Order for the Transportation of any Offender or Offenders made by any Justice of Oyer and Terminer, Great Session, or Gaol Delivery, for any County, City, Liberty, Borough or Place, during the Continuance of the Assizes or Sessions.
Evidence given before Committee inquiring into Transportation Act of 1784.
Evan Nepean, Esquire, being also examined, informed the Committee, That in consequence of the Representations made to Government, of the crouded and dangerous state of the Gaols, the Censor Hulk was hired of Mr. Duncan Campbell, for the Reception of 250 Convicts - That the Dunkirk Hulk, a King's Ship, lying in Ordinary at Plymouth, was appointed for the Reception of Prisoners from the Western Gaols, and very lately an old India Man has been hired by Mr Campbell for the temporary Accommodation of 250 more - That the Censor contains 250, some of whom were originally sentenced to America; that there are 100 on board the Dunkirk, of whom 46 are under their original Sentences, and the Remainder are Convicts returned from Transportation, who are remanded to their original Sentences, except about 10, who are Capital Respites - That in the Ceres there are about 150, and sufficient Room to accommodate 100 more - That these are all the Places which have been appointed for the Reception of Convicts, at least all with which the Secretaries of State have had any Connection. . . .
Mr, Nepean further acquainted the Committee, That a Plan has been suggested, for the Transportation of Convicts to the Island of Lemane, about 400 Miles up the River Gambia - That many other Places have been submitted to the Secretary of State, but in his Opinion this is the Plan which Government will prefer, the African company having refused to take any more into their Ports and Settlements; and that he knows of no other regular Plan offered, with regards to Africa. . . .- Mr Nepean further added, That the Reason why the Persons first named are to be sent to Africa, is, that they are notorious Felons, who are every Day expected to break Prison, some of them have already made Attempts to do so, and are a Class of People too dangerous to remain in this Country; and it is thought there is no proper Place in America to transport them to, at least within the King's Dominions. . . .
Mr. Henry Smeatham, who resided near Four Years on the Coast of Africa . . . said, That if 200 Convicts were left on an Island in the River Gambia, without any Medical Assistance than what they might give to each other, not One in 100 would survive the first Six Months, as Persons long confined in Prisons are peculiarly unfit to struggle with an African Climate. . . .
Opinions on Africa as a Receptacle for Felons, 1785.
Mr. John Boon . . . Surgeon to the Army in Africa . . . said, That from about the Middle of July to the beginning of November, Putrid Fevers usually prevail; and that Fluxes are very general from December to the End of March; and that the former Disorder is the most fatal to Europeans, Two Thirds of the King's Forces having perished every Year. . . .
Sir George Young being also examined, acquainted the Committee, That he had been Four Times at Gambia and Senegal . . . That he had always considered Gambia as the most unhealthy Part of the Coast. . . .
Sir George Young confirmed the Testimony of other Witnesses with regard to the Impossibility of restraining a Colony of Convicts, without Order or Government, within the Limits assigned to them; and also expressed his Apprehension that none of the Traders, who now navigate the River in their Long Boats, after such an Establishment took place would venture up to it, for fear of being plundered. . . . Being further examined as to the Practicability of Europeans subsisting themselves by Field Labour within the Tropics he said, That it had never been attempted, as Death would be the Consequence of their continuing an Hour exposed to the Sun.
The Pitt Government's Plan for Botany Bay Settlement. 1786.
The several gaols and places for the confinement of felons in this kingdom being in so crowded a state that the greatest danger is to be apprehended, not only from their escape, but from infectious distempers, which may hourly be expected to break out amongst them, his Majesty, desirous of preventing by every possible means the ill consequences which might happen from either of these causes, has been pleased to signify to me his royal commands that measures should immediately be pursued for sending out of this kingdom such of the convicts as are under sentence or order of transportation.
The Nautilus sloop, which, upon the recommendation of a committee of the House of Commons, had been sent to explore the southern coast of Africa, in order to find an eligible situation for the reception of the said convicts, where from their industry they might soon be likely to obtain means of subsistence, having lately returned, and it appearing from the reports of her officers that the several parts of the coast which they examined between 15º 50' south and the latitude of 33º 00' are sandy and barren, and from other causes unfit for settlement of that description, his Majesty has thought it advisable to fix on Botany Bay, situated on the coast of New South Wales, the latitude of about 33 degrees south, which, according to the accounts given by the late Captain Cook, as well as the representatives of persons who accompanied him during his last voyage, and who have been consulted on the subject, is looked upon as a place likely to answer the above purposes.
I am, therefore, commanded to signify to your Lordships his Majesty's pleasure that you do forthwith take such measures as may be necessary for providing a proper number of vessels for the conveyance of 750 convicts to Botany bay, together with such provisions, necessities, and implements for agriculture as may be necessary for their use after their arrival. . . .
According to the best opinions that can be obtained, it is supposed that a quantity of provisions equal to two years' consumption should be provided, which must be issued from time to time, according to the discretion of the superintendent, in the expenditure of which he will, of course, be guided by the proportion of food which the country and the labour of the new settlers may produce. . . .
In the meantime, I have only to recommend it to your Lordships to cause every possible expedition to be used in preparing the shipping for the reception of the said convicts, and for transporting the supplies of provisions and necessities for their use to the place of their destination.
HEADS OF A PLAN
Heads of a plan for effectually disposing of convicts, and rendering their transportation reciprocally beneficial both to themselves and to the State, by the establishment of a colony in New South Wales, a country which, by the fertility and salubrity of the climate, connected with the remoteness of its situation (from whence it is hardly possible for persons to return without permission), seems peculiarly adapted to answer the views of Government with respect to the providing a remedy for the evils likely to result from the late alarming and numerous increase of felons in this country, and more particularly in the metropolis.
It is proposed that a ship of war of a proper class, with a part of her guns mounted, and a sufficient number of men on board for her navigation, and a tender of about 200 tons burthen, commanded by discreet officers, should be got ready as soon as possible to serve as an escort to the convict ships and for other purposes hereinafter mentioned.
That, in addition to their crews, they should take on board two companies of marines to form a military establishment on shore (not only for the protection of the settlement, if requisite, against the natives, but for the preservation of good order), together with an assortment of stores, utensils, and implements, necessary for erecting habitations and for agriculture, and such qantities of provisions as may be proper for the use of the crews.
As many of the marines as possible should be artificers, such as carpenters, sawyers, smiths, potters (if possible), and some husbandmen. To have a chaplain on board, with a surgeon, and one mate at least; the former to remain at the settlement.
That these vessels should touch at the Cape of Good Hope, or any other places that may be convenient, for any seed that may be requisite to be taken from thence, and for such live stock as they can possibly contain, which, it is supposed, can be procured there without any sort of difficulty, and at most reasonable rates, for the use of the settlement at large.
That Government should immediately provide a certain number of ships of a proper burthen to receive on board at least seven or eight hundred convicts, and that one of them should be properly fitted for the accommodation of the women, to prevent their intercourse with the men.
That these ships should take on board as much provisions as they can possibly stow, or at least a sufficient quantity for two years' consumption; supposing one year to be issued at whole allowance, and the other year's provisions at half allowance, which will last two years longer, by which time, it is presumed, the colony, with the live stock and grain which may be raised by a common industry on the part of the new settlers, will be fully sufficient for their maintenance and support.
That, in addition to the crews of the ships appointed to contain the convicts, a company of marines should be divided between them, to be employed as guards for preventing ill consequences that might arise form dissatisfaction amongst the convicts, and for the protection of the crew in the navigation of the ship from insults that might be offered by the convicts.
That each of the ships should have on board at least two surgeons' mates, to attend to the wants of the sick, and should be supplied with a proper assortment of medicines and instruments, and that two of them should remain with the settlement.
After the arrival of the ships which are intended to convey the convicts, the ship of war and tender may be employed in obtaining livestock from the Cape, or from the Molucca Islands, a sufficient quantity of which may be brought from either of those places to the new settlement in two or three trips; or the tender, if it should be thought most adviseable, may be employed in conveying to the new settlement a further number of women from the Friendly Islands, New Caledonia, Etc., which are contiguous thereto, and from whence any number may be procured without difficulty; and without a sufficient proportion of that sex it is well-known that it would be impossible to preserve the settlement from gross irregularities and disorders.
The whole regulation and management of the settlement should be committed to the care of a discreet officer, and provision should be made, in all cases, both civil and military, by special instructions under the Great Seal or otherwise, as may be thought proper. Upon the whole, it may be observed with great force and truth that the difference of expence (whatever the method of carrying the convicts thither may be adopted) that this mode of disposing of them and that of the usual ineffective one is too trivial to be a consideration with Government, at least in comparison with the great object obtained by it, especially now the evil is increased to such an alarming degree, from the inadequacy of all other expedients that have hitherto been tried or suggested.
It may not be amiss to remark in favour of this plan that considerable advantages will arise from the cultivation of New Zealand hemp or flax-plant in the new intended settlements, the supply of which would be of great consequence to us as a naval power, as our manufacturers are of opinion that canvas made of it would be superior in strength and beauty to any canvas made of the European material, and that a cable of the circumference of ten inches made from the former would be superior in strength to one of eighteen inches made of the latter. The threads or filaments of this New Zealand plant are formed by nature with most exquisite delicacy, and may be so minutely divided as to be manufactured into the finest linens.
Most of the Asiatic productions may also without doubt be cultivated in the new settlement, and in a few years may render our recourse to our European neighbours for those productions unnecessary.
It may also be proper to attend to the possibility of procuring from New Zealand any quantity of masts and ship timber for the use of our fleets in India, as the distance between the two countries is not greater than that between Great Britain and America. It grows close to the water's edge, of size and quality superior to any hitherto known, and may be obtained without difficulty.
Staff Establishment for the Settlement of New South Wales: -
Yearly Salary
£ s d
The Naval Commander to be appointed Governer or Superintendent-General 500 0 0
The Commanding Officer of the Marines to be appointed Lieut.-Gov. or Dept. Superintendent 250 0 0
The Commissary of Stores and Provisions, for himself and assistants (to be appointed or named by the contractors for the provisions) 200 0 0
Pay of a surgeon 182 10 0
Ditto of two mates 182 10 0
365 0 0
Chaplain 182 10 0
1,497 10 0